Welcome to Pedagogy   |   Sign In

Correctional Nurse Legal Briefs - Prison Litigation Reform Act - PLRA

Recently I was contacted by the wife of an inmate about his poor medical care. He is currently in a state prison. She wanted to interest a legal firm in taking on the case and was wondering what information she would need to gather. One of the first things I asked was about the actions her husband had already taken to remedy the situation. For example, had he already requested treatments through the normal sick call process or submitted grievances about his medical care?

Legal recourse is a common place to go when inmates are not receiving needed healthcare. A 205 survey sited in this article found medical care to be the number one litigation topic in both jails and prisons.

The Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA) was passed in 1996 to require preliminary actions before a legal claim is heard by the court. This legislation was originally proposed to limit frivolous inmate lawsuits regarding their conditions of confinement and is limited to civil cases (not medical malpractice). See an earlier post on Section 1983 (Civil Rights) cases.

Key Points of PLRA
  • Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies – An inmate must first use the internal grievance system to the full extent (including any appeals process) before taking legal action on a claim
  • Mental or Emotional Injury – cannot be claimed without first showing physical injury
  • Screening and Dismissal – PLRA allows a case to be screened by the court and dismissed as frivolous even before the defense is required to reply.
  • Three-Strikes Clause – Upfront filing fees are generally waived or greatly decreased for inmates due to poverty. However, after three prior lawsuits dismissed as “frivolous, malicious, or failing to state a claim for relief”, this waiver is exhausted. Further filings will require the full fee be paid upfront.
The number of lawsuits filed by inmates greatly increased from 1970 to 1995. More than 40,000 inmate claims clogged the legal system in 1995. The PLRA aimed to reduce frivolous and unnecessary inmate lawsuits by creating some boundaries on the types and frequency of legal claims. Lawsuits filed by inmates have been reduced to around 25,000 per year.

What has been your experience with PRLA? Do you think it is a good idea?

This post originally appeared in CorrectionalNurse.Net

Guest post by Dr. Lorry Schoenly nurse author and educator specializing in the field of correctional health care. She has written 6 continuing education courses especially for the Correctional Healthcare Campus.

Correctional Healthcare Processes
Safety in the Correctional Setting
The Correctional Healthcare Patient and Environment
Medication Administration in the Correctional Setting
Risk and Documentation in the Correctional Setting
Special Issues in Corrections

You may see all of the online continuing education offered at the Correctional Healthcare Campus by clicking View Entire Catalog.

You may purchase the collection of Correctional Courses in a cost saving package: Correctional Healthcare Nurse Continuing Education Package

Memberships are also available to institutions that would like to provide a library of education to their staff. See Memberships for more information and to request pricing.
Posted: 5/3/2016 11:01:00 PM
Blog post currently doesn't have any comments.
Leave comment

 Security code
Copyright © 2020 Pedagogy, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by Kentico